Sunday, June 3, 2018

Dear Betsy DeVos, I Will NEVER Report My Students to ICE by Steven Singer

Teachers fill a lot of roles in our public schools.

We’re mentors to kids in need.

We’re homework-givers, pencil-providers, idea-encouragers, lunch-buyers, scrape-bandagers, hand-holders, hug-givers, good listeners, counselors, caregivers and – yes – sometimes even butt-kickers.

It’s no wonder that we occasionally get mistaken for mothers and fathers.

But one thing we will never be is a snitch.

She’s not going to say what we should do one way or another. She’s just saying that this is something we COULD do if we wanted.

If that results in those kids and their families being deported, well we are a nation of laws, after all.

It’s a remark that sounds so reasonable to some folks.

Luckily, I speak dog whistle.

So did the U.S. Supreme Court back in 1982 when justices ruled in Plyler v. Doe that schools cannot deny children their right to a free education based on immigration status.

When kids are afraid to learn because they or their parents or extended family may be undocumented, that has a smothering affect on the classroom.

When ICE raids a local business, we see a sudden drop in class attendance.

So if students thought their teachers or principals were scrutinizing them to determine their citizenship status, we’d be discouraging many with brown skin or extra-national credentials from ever coming back.

By suggesting that educators have a choice whether to obey established law or to become self-appointed border patrol officers, DeVos actually is prescribing how we should act.

Well, not this teacher, Betsy.

Not now. Not EVER.

Teachers are not the enforcers of our broken, bent and biased immigration policy. It is not our job to oblige xenophobia and bigotry.

It is our job to teach, to protect and inspire.

Sure, I’ve made my fair share of calls to parents, healthcare professionals and Child Protective Services.

But I did that to protect my kids. And I do think of them as my kids.

When these little people come toddling into my class, I take a kind of ownership of them.

For the time they’re here, we’re family. I take interest in their lives and they take interest in mine.

They know all about my wife and daughter, my parents and grandparents. And I know about theirs.

We don’t just learn grammar, reading and writing. We share our lives with each other.

We share a mutual trust and respect.

If I reported even a single student for a suspected immigration violation, I would lose that forever.

Hispanic names have become Anglicized. Angelo has becomes Angel. Julio has become Jules. Jorge is now George.

The dulcet melody of Spanish has been silenced. You’ll only hear it in muffled voices if you wander by a few lockers, but never in class.

My kids aren’t even 13 yet, but many of them have already learned to hide.

Don’t appear different. Don’t let anyone know your roots extend beyond national borders.

Be “normal.” Be homogenized, bland American.

That’s the world we’ve built and it’s the one that DeVos is encouraging with her tin pot nationalism.

Some things don’t change when you cross municipal lines – human decency is one of them.

So I won’t be reporting any of my students to ICE.

I won’t help the Gestapo separate parents and children based on citizenship status.

White supremacy was bad enough before Trump was elected. I won’t help the unfortunately named Department of Homeland Security become the protector of a new white trash Fatherland.

I will defend my students. I will stand up for their safety and their rights.

That’s just what we do in public school. We look after our own.

Like this post? I’ve written a book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A Public School Teacher Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now available from Garn Press. Ten percent of the proceeds go to the Badass Teachers Association. Check it out!


  1. Packers And Movers Hyderabad Local Household Shifting Service, Get Free Best Price Quotes Local Packers and Movers in Hyderabad List, Compare Charges, Save Money And Time @ Packers And Movers Hyderabad

  2. DIPA will ensure that students graduate as good citizens that are prepared for the transition to higher education, or the next viable step of their career choice. We will work in partnership with the parents and students and our online education partner AHS, to strengthen and improve the quality of the experience for all that attend DIPA.

    if you want more just look here "students"

  3. [4:09 PM, 6/13/2018] +91 91762 14797: Thank you for sharing such useful and informative article. keep sharing
    [4:09 PM, 6/13/2018] +91 91762 14797: The Best School in Perambur
    The Best School in Vyasarpadi

  4. On the other hand you can interface with QuickBooks POS Support that is a solid QuickBooks counseling firm contracting top QuickBooks experts. They are proficient in taking care of QuickBooks POS Error 1330 and flawlessly settling them. They guarantee finish goals in a base hold up time.

  5. On confronting this QuickBooks POS Error 121 when you visit the assistance and programming refreshes page inside QuickBooks POS you will go over a product refresh that will settle the issue. The refresh should be downloaded and kept running on the server and the work region.

  6. We've been all educated it to buy equipment or gadget, shopper conserves for the same and aims an incredible offer. Now picture if just soon after buying a handsome sum of cash over a Software, it breaks. The drop is inexpressible, and that is whichever substitute support. The suppliers click here are cheap and rapidly, the rationale remaining shopper simplicity at any price tag. The Apple Internet site Apple Customer Service Number 24 Hours might be a 24/seven helpline which may be retrieved what. Visit Here:

  7. Digital Marketing is about achieving customers through channels, which include search engines, social networking, email, and much more. These Search Engine Optimization with agents and facilitate just one to 1 communication between the companies and customers. Any sort of promoting that includes marketing of products or results and services by way more info of any Digital Marketing factor is named digital marketing and promotion.

    Read More:

  8. Apple is a corporation that is definitely well-known. The products are exceptional. No gadget manufacture all around the world can offer you gizmos and solutions. And For that explanation, that gadget performs appropriately within our have on a daily basis dwelling Furthermore the mend help furnished by the iPhone customer service phone number professionals may even be marvelous. This helpline was set in place to meet Each individual and every more information tough when utilizing their gadgets which ended up esteemed which a buyer could maybe possibly practical experience. These industry professionals are performing for many years, and that's the rationale. If you have any query dial Apple Customer Service Number 24 Hours which lets you take care of your queries. Visit Here:

  9. Nice Blog, thank you so much for sharing such an amazing information with us.
    Freight Forwarders in Delhi

  10. At times arranging a trip is as enjoyable as having a family vacation. But at times you would like someone else to try and do every one of the work for you and just book a trip package. get more info For the reason that, let's face it, sorting through motels, itineraries, and flights could be a frightening process whenever you just choose to get away. Moreover, it is possible to frequently obtain far better deals if you guide a deal here you get Rajasthan Holiday Packages, Himachal Holiday Packages and also Uttarakhand Holiday Packages and much more. Visit Here:

  11. Female Bangalore Escorts Service is offered to a best horny lady and one in every of the foremost happening place in Bharat for fun, joy and services, services like which supplies you pleasure loads of enjoyment. Bangalore Female Escorts will cause you to come for additional, that is the talent they need once it involves on bed action. You have got interested in a hot lady you contact Bangalore Escorts Service of the street and luxuriate in tp your tough life. Visit Here:

  12. You might crave For added and points will feel sweeter than before. Have the ability to dig deep into their significant property and take pleasure in the heat of your human entire body. The sweet essence from their In general entire body is probably going to make you get there for more in satisfaction and ecstasy. Prepare for the ultimate term functional experience of everyday life. The wild exciting awaits your presence at the rear of the shut doorways. These are usually responsible pleasures of existence. Hygiene is of fantastic importance, which gorgeous Bangalore Escorts Services focus strongly on this portion. Visit Here:

  13. If you're looking for VIP call ladies Bangalore, a right amount of choices are offered to get picked. Nevertheless, right before selecting a specific just one, it’s Essential making sure that the providers are scrutinized thoroughly to own explicit knowledge about the safety Component of the process. There are several escort solutions readily available in Bangalore Escorts, but more info not all of these are reliable ample to be hired. Visit Here:

  14. Nice blog, you put valuable information in your blog. I’m really thankful to you for sharing this blog with us. Ogen Information is one of the best Website Designing Company in Delhi.
    PPC Service in Delhi

  15. Your content in this blog is really impressive, I’m really thankful to you for this information. Visit Y&H Cargo for Shipping and Freight Forwarding Services.
    Shipping Company in Delhi

  16. Acquiring Among the many listing of busiest lodgings of Bangalore listed here Hyatt plan is Probably probably the most beloved destinations to revenue Escorts in Bangalore and with excellent and astonishing types from Karnataka escort Business in Karnataka that you are likely to include effortlessness in your accumulating and also your night will sprout the blooms of snuggle and kisses.